The Cocktail Lovers Magazine Issue 48



The bartender’s cut

ByThe Cocktail Lovers


“The Tough Mudder of spirits awards” is how Dan Priseman describes the Bartender’s Best Awards. Not being
remotely sycophantic, we’re inclined to agree. Who better than bartenders to judge the quality of the spirits that go into your glass? And to make this particular awards even more interesting – how about getting them to judge the quality of the liquid versus the price of the product in a ‘double blind’ process?

It’s not rocket science but funnily enough, spirits awards have never been done like this before. Not in the UK at any rate. So Priseman together with James Triffo set about putting this right. “People don’t purchase a product based on age statements, they purchase based on a price range they can afford,” says Triffo. “Likewise, bartenders use products based on price when recommending drinks to customers. We’re the first and only spirit awards using this methodology and believe it’s the fairest and most accurate way to judge products used across UK bars. It’s been a humbling process and a real curving curve.”

Brands were charged £200 to submit their products, with all proceeds going to support bartenders with training at the Wine Spirit Education Trust (WSET). It took ten months from conception to the announcements which were made earlier this week. During this time the invited bartenders were put through their paces, evaluating and
scoring the products based on their merits in accordance with the WSET systematic approach to tasting. “It’s a true double-blind process which ensures that no individual in the room knows which liquid is in which glass,”
adds Priseman. “It really is a rigorous process, designed to find the best products available in the UK.”

Forget runner’s-up places, the Bartender’s Best Awards only has time for winners. See the results below. But first, a few words with the founders:

Was setting up the Bartender’s Best Awards harder or easier than anticipated?
JT: Realising awards are already congested we really asked ourselves does the industry need another one? After looking at the majority we understood that many are born from a background outside of our industry and are in place to support a larger business. Another thing we addressed was the fact that awards are often judged by people the cocktail bar industry has trouble recognising. We wanted to change all that with the BBAs.
DP: When we first conceived the awards, we thrashed out a basic framework, and decided that we could manage this ourselves certainly in year one, with just a team of three. It turns out there was a lot more to it than just contacting brands and arranging tastings, and the project pushed us to the limit. I think we’ve both agreed that in year two we will be expanding the team, but I’m glad that we’ve experienced every aspect firsthand so we know every detail of our business.
How many bartenders were involved in the process?
JT: We’ve had over 80 bartenders participate in the inaugural year. Many more applied but didn’t fit the criteria of being a full time UK-based bartender – we’ve founds lots of international bartenders are really supportive which naturally leads us to imagine taking this into other territories around the world in a few years.
Any surprises?
DP: The results speak for themselves but we had really hoped to see some surprises coming through. I think you can see from the results that some of the larger brands that perhaps bartenders assume are just big budget and no substance, have actually shone through. Likewise, some of the small challenger brands have done amazingly well and shown that the ‘category leaders’ should probably be looking over their shoulders.
What are you both proudest of about the first BBAs?
JT: How humbled and amazed we are from the support that the drinks community have offered us; bartenders, brands and everyone else giving their time to make this happen.
DP: Yeah, the support has been incredible, and seeing not only those directly involved in the project, but our greater bar tending community engage with the BBA has given us a huge sense of achievement.

Category Winners

Fortified Wine
Cocchi Vermouth di Torino

Bitter Truth Creole Bitters

Bitter Truth Golden Falernum

Belvedere Unfiltered

Geranium 55

Pierre Ferrand 1840

Appleton 21yo

Chivas 25yo

Tapatio Blanco

2014 Grand Champion
Chivas Regal 25 year old

Sub-category winners

(A minimum of three products had to be entered in each category, otherwise they were not considered)

Premium: Maison Fontaine

Dry/white: Mancino Blanco
Sweet/red: Cocchi Vermouth di Torino

Aromatic: Bitter Truth Creole
Spiced: Dale Degroff’s Pimento bitters

Standard: Absolut
Premium: Belvedere Pure
Luxury: Belvedere Unfiltered

Flavoured Vodka
Standard: Ketel One Citron
Premium: Absolut Craft Herbacious Lemon Blanco

Standard: El Jimador
Premium: Tapatio

Reposado Tequila
Premium: Olmeca Altos

Extra Anejo Tequila
Luxury: Don Julio 1942

Japanese Whisky
Standard: Yamazaki Distiller’s Reserve
Premium: Hibiki 12yo

Blended Scotch Whisky
Standard: Chivas 12yo
Premium: Johnnie Walker Platinum
Luxury: Chivas 25yo

Peated Scotch Malt
Premium: Lagavullin 16yo

Unpeated Scotch Whisky
Standard: Auchentoshan 3 wood

Grain Whiskey
Haig Club

Standard: Bulleit Bourbon
Premium: Old Forester
Luxury: Hudson Four Grain

American Rye Whiskey
Standard: Bulleit Rye
Premium: High West Double Rye
Luxury: Hudson Manhattan Rye

London Dry Gin
Standard: Hayman’s
Premium: Geranium
Luxury: Ford’s Gin

Old Tom Style
Premium: Hammer & Son Old English

High Strength Gin
Premium: Geranium 55

Aged Gin
Burrough’s Reserve

Sloe Gin
Premium: Plymouth Sloe Gin

White Rum
Standard: Cana Brava
Premium: St. Nicholas Abbey
Overproof: Wray & Nephew

Golden Rum
Standard: Plantation Guatemala
Premium: El Dorado 15yo
Luxury: Appleton 21yo
Overproof: Plantation

White: Abelha
Gold: Abelha

Standard: Pierre Ferrand 1840

Fruit: Pierre Ferrand Dry Curacao
Spiced: Bitter Truth Golden Falernum
Herbal: Licor 43
Floral: Bitter Truth Violet Liqueur

Picture of The Cocktail Lovers

The Cocktail Lovers

The Cocktail Lovers are Mr G and Ms S, a man and a woman who share a passion for cocktails. (We also happen to be married, so we’re cocktail lovers in more ways than one…)


Be the first to hear the latest news, get sneaky peeks inside upcoming issues of The Cocktail Lovers magazine, receive special offers and lots more. (And we promise we won’t share your details with anyone else).

To get the latest copy of our gorgeous print magazine just click on the cover!

One Response

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The Cocktail Lovers magazine is packed with features, fashion, food, travel, interviews, news, recipes – all written from a cocktail lover’s perspective. Published four times a year, take your pick from the luxurious print edition or get your fix in the page-turning digital format – either way, it couldn’t be easier to start a subscription or order back issues. And why keep all the cocktail goodness to yourself? Share the love by setting up a gift subscription. We ship pretty much everywhere in the world, so we’ve got you covered. Start your subscription today!

The Cocktail Lovers Magazine Issue 48
The Cocktail Lovers Magazine Issue 47
The Cocktail Lovers Magazine Issue 46
The Cocktail Lovers Magazine 45 Cover
The Cocktail Lovers Magazine Issue 48
The Cocktail Lovers Magazine Issue 48

JOIN us!

Join us at The Cocktail Lovers and be the first to hear the latest news, get our new magazine and receive specials offers. (And we don’t share your details with anyone else.)